A recent caller I heard on The Dave Ramsey radio show had an interesting question about balancing her portfolio when she was investing in both stocks and mutual funds. Her husband loved investing in real estate and liked to be very hands-on with their properties. She was more comfortable with owning stocks and mutual funds because they offered liquidity - she knew she could get her hands on the funds quickly if something terrible happened and she had to cash out her stocks in a day or two.
The call caught my attention because it’s a topic my husband and I have discussed extensively as well.
Here’s What Dave Ramsey Says About How Much Real Estate to Own:
For the record, the "expert" Dave Ramsey said he would recommend somewhere between a 50/50 portfolio split and a 75/25 portfolio split (that’s 75% real estate and 25% stocks). Dave is a big real estate fan and he said his personal portfolio is weighted 75% toward real estate because he doesn’t mind the hassle factor that real estate presents and he thinks it’s worth it to get superior rates of return.
The big BUT here is that Dave Ramsey only buys real estate free and clear. After going bankrupt himself, he does not believe in taking on debt, so he buys properties all cash at a discount, with no loans at any time. Therefore, when he owns $100,000 in real estate, that means one property worth $100,000; not 4 properties with $25,000 equity each and $300,000 in debt in total.
This is an important distinction because debt (also known as leverage) can improve your rate of return on a property, but it can also increase the risk. If you are buying real estate WITH DEBT, as most of us are, I think it makes sense to be a little more cautious.
If You Leverage Your Properties, Grow Your Portfolio Prudently
I’ve talked before about the importance of being able to pay for your properties long term. With a mutual fund investment strategy, if you go through a rough patch - like a job loss - you can stop making contributions to your funds for a few months while you get back on your feet.
With real estate, you don’t have that flexibility. If the property has negative cash flow, goes vacant, or needs repair, you have to keep writing checks to take care of your property, whether it’s convenient or not. (And face it, when is it EVER convenient to feed a property?)
My partners and I own an apartment building that suffered roof damage in a recent storm. It’s needed over $200,000 in repairs which we’ve had to pull together from our personal accounts. It’s been important to have the liquidity to handle that type of emergency to avoid the property being further damaged due to the problem going unresolved.
As You Buy More Real Estate, Stockpile More Cash
So, how much of a cash reserve do you need if you own real estate that’s leveraged? It’s hard to create a specific formula in the abstract, but here are some issues to take into account:
- How much equity do you have in the property? If you needed to liquidate quickly (within 6 months) would you be able to do so? Would you walk away with cash or would you have to pay out at closing?
- Does the property have negative cash flow or positive cash flow on a regular basis?
- How well diversified are you? (The more different properties you have in different areas of the country, the less likely you would suffer from a "catastrophic" down turn in the market in terms of falling rents or property values.)
- What is the sales and rental market like? If you have a waiting list of buyers or renters there is less risk than if there are relatively few people shopping for what you have to offer.
Personally, I keep a "real estate cash account" separate from my other mutual fund investment accounts or personal funds. In this cash account, I keep about a 3-month reserve to pay for each property’s mortgage if it were to go vacant. (If you have a smaller number of units, this is an appropriate sized reserve, if you have a lot of units, you probably don’t need to keep that much cash on hand. You’re well diversified and chances are not EVERY unit is going to go vacant at the same time.) I also keep funds available for major upcoming repairs and capital expenses.
This account is just good safety/housekeeping for my real estate portfolio, I don’t include this balance in my "investable assets" column. I would not spend these reserve funds on a down payment for a new property, for example. I keep them liquid (and therefore, not "invested") so I can always safely manage the properties I have. Kind of like a trust account or operating account that you might keep with your property manager
Deciding Where To Invest Your Next $25,000
In terms of portfolio balance, right now I would say my net worth is balanced at about 80% equity in real estate and 20% in mutual funds. That’s mostly because I’ve been working full time as a real estate investor for the past several years and acquiring property at a rapid rate, much of it purchased with private funding. So, my real estate portfolio has grown very quickly through my efforts. However, I haven’t been generating lots of CASH to invest in mutual funds. (You still can’t build value in your stock portfolio through sweat-equity work, as far as I know…
)
At this point, my husband and I still want to continue acquiring real estate, but we are focusing our CASH INVESTMENT efforts into building up our mutual fund portfolio, so that our investments are balanced closer to a 50/50 mix.
Basically, we do this:
- When we get cash - from the sale of a property, from contract or employment income, or as a gift, we first make sure we have enough money on hand to fund our day-to-day expenses and we check to make sure our reserve accounts are topped up. (Outside the real estate reserve fund, we also keep 3-6 months of living expenses available to us in a money market fund. We tend to go for a big "emergency fund" because we consider our investments illiquid. We don’t want to be forced to pull money out of our mutual funds, retirement accounts or real estate.)
- Our second step is to make sure we’re getting the employer match on Ben’s 401(k), fully funding our Roth IRA’s, and then we put additional budgeted amounts into the 401(k). (The tax-exempt annual contribution limit is $15,500 for a 401(k), I believe.)
- Any savings after that get divided up into our investments. Right now we are working on building up our mutual fund account balances so we’ll be closer to a 50/50 split with our net worth divided between real estate and mutual funds.
(Unlike Dave Ramsey, we DO believe in good debt, so we’re just counting property equity, not property value, in that figure.) One conservative way to estimate the value of your real estate’s equity is something my friend Steve Maxwell taught me. Rather than using the "appraised value" to determine your real estate equity, use the "liquidation value." For example, if I had to sell a property and anticipated paying a 6% realtor commission plus 2% in other costs (repair, vacancy, etc.) and I thought I would get about 4% less than appraised value because the market was slow, I would subtract those costs from my appraisal of the property’s value, to estimate how much I would really net if I were to sell the home. In this example, that would mean taking 88% of the appraised value and then subtracting the loan balance to determine my equity.
- Each year my husband and I review our holdings, we re-calculate how much we have in real estate and how much we have in stocks and what our goal is for that year. We might want to acquire one house at 70 cents on the dollar, one commercial property through Grassland Investments, LLC with 100% financing, and put a certain amount into stocks each year. Then we set up an automatic purchase plan to buy the mutual funds at Vanguard and get to work looking at the types of properties we are interested in buying.
You’ve Heard It Before: Slow and Steady Wins The Race
One thing that I learned from acquiring a lot of houses in quick succession earlier in my career is that you don’t want to just buy as many houses as possible. You want to buy the best houses, and make sure that for each one you buy, you’re keeping a certain amount of money liquid, too, so that you can afford to take care of the house after you’ve purchased it. A big mistake that a lot of investors make is buying a ton of houses with leverage, only to have the house of cards come tumbling down once they hit a down swing in the economy had have several extended vacancies, lowered rents, or expensive repairs. It’s much better to grow your portfolio in a sustainable way.
Holla’ Back
So, now you know what I do, and what Dave Ramsey recommends. I’m curious to hear how you handle this issue. How much of your portfolio is in real estate versus the stock market? Do you have any other investment categories that you allocate a significant portion of your investable assets to? Comment below!